The Right Roofing Material: A Handy Comparison Guide

admin Rochester Roofing Contractors Leave a Comment

What roofing material should you choose for your Rochester home?Scraping together enough money for a new roof is only half the battle; you also need to figure out what kind of roof you want. There are many different styles of roofs that use many different materials, so it’s important to choose the best option for your needs. Luckily, we’ve put together a handy guide to help you understand the differences between all the available roofing materials and find one that works for your Rochester, NY home.

Why It Matters

The roofing material you choose for your home will affect the way your home looks, the maintenance your roof requires, and the lifespan of your roof. Some materials look great but don’t last as long as others do or are environmentally friendly but very expensive. Knowing the differences between these materials will help you make a decision you won’t regret, which is an important feat to accomplish when you’re spending thousands on renovations.


There are several different materials you can choose from for your roof, with the most common being asphalt shingles. Within each of these materials are various options. You want to find a material that’s durable, looks good, is affordable, and is eco-friendly.


Asphalt shingles are the most common roofing material because they’re versatile, fairly durable, inexpensive, and resistant to fire and wind. Because this is such a common roofing material, constant improvements are being made. Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration Limited Lifetime shingles are one great example of these improvements. These shingles are perfect for the weather in Rochester, because they have great wind resistance with a wind rating of 130 mph. Owens Corning SureNail technology means these shingles will stay on your roof and nail blow through won’t be a problem.


Metal roofs are also fairly common because they’re durable, eco-friendly, lightweight, fire- and wind-resistant, and can be inexpensive. You can opt for recycled materials for an eco-friendlier option and your old metal roofing can be recycled when you have it replaced.

Plastic Polymer

Plastic polymer roofing comes in the form of synthetic shingles that usually look like wood or slate. They last pretty long and don’t require too much maintenance, plus they have good fire and wind resistance. Some are even made from recycled materials.

Clay & Concrete

You can also have a tile roof made of clay or concrete. Clay tiles are fairly expensive and heavy, but they do provide good fire resistance. Concrete tiles are also heavy but a bit less expensive, and they also provide good fire resistance. Neither type of tile roof is particularly known for its wind resistance.

Slate & Wood

Slate roofing is something you don’t see every day because it’s expensive and has its disadvantages. However, slate is a decent choice for its wind and fire resistance. The other material you might see—but not so often—is wood, usually cedar. Wood roofs are moderately expensive, don’t last long, and require lots of maintenance, but they provide decent wind resistance.

Other Considerations

Of course, your roof is only as good as the sum of its parts, so it’s important to make sure you choose all the right options for your new roof. An externally baffled ridge vent is the best choice for Rochester homes because it will prevent high winds from entering the inflow vent and preventing the attic from being ventilated. The underlayment you choose also matters. We recommend using an underlayment from the manufacturer who made your shingles. Not only are these two products designed to work together by the same brand, using one brand for your whole roof ensures you have a warranty on everything.

Making all these decisions can be a bit overwhelming, but we’re here to help. Give JJ Construction a call at (585) 865-5428 to learn more about having a new roof installed in Rochester, NY.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *